The Best Gifts for a White Elephant Party That Everyone Will Want to Steal

White Elephant parties are a blast, but finding the perfect gift can be tricky. You want something everyone will fight over, not a dusty old mug. The goal is to bring a present that’s so good, people actually want to steal it. No more awkward moments with unwanted items! This guide will help you pick the best gifts for a white elephant party, ensuring your present is the star of the show.

Key Takeaways

  • Choose gifts that appeal to a wide range of people.
  • Consider practical items that can be used often.
  • Think about trending items or popular games.
  • Sometimes, a bit of humor can make a gift memorable.
  • Don’t forget about comfort and relaxation items.

1. Air Fryer

Okay, hear me out. An air fryer might seem like a boring gift, but trust me, it’s a total game-changer for a White Elephant party. Everyone secretly wants one, but not everyone wants to buy one for themselves. It’s the perfect blend of practical and desirable, making it a hot commodity when the stealing starts.

I mean, who doesn’t love crispy food without all the oil? Plus, there are so many different models out there, from basic ones to fancy ones with all the bells and whistles. You can even find compact air fryer options that won’t take up too much counter space.

Here’s why an air fryer is a genius White Elephant gift:

  • It’s universally appealing – who doesn’t like food?
  • It’s practical – people will actually use it.
  • It’s steal-worthy – everyone will want to upgrade their kitchen game.

I brought an air fryer to a White Elephant party last year, and it was the most stolen item by far. People were practically fighting over it! It just goes to show that sometimes the most practical gifts are the most coveted.

Seriously, consider an air fryer. It’s a gift that keeps on giving (delicious, crispy food).

2. Wordle Board Game

Wordle board game box, dice, and cards

So, you know Wordle, right? The online word puzzle that took over everyone’s lives for a hot minute? Well, guess what? Now it’s a board game! And honestly, it’s a pretty awesome White Elephant gift.

The Wordle board game brings all the fun of the online version to your tabletop. One person (or team) picks a secret five-letter word, and everyone else tries to guess it, using the color-coded clues to narrow down the possibilities. It’s surprisingly addictive, even in its physical form.

It’s a great gift because almost everyone knows what Wordle is, so there’s instant recognition and a low barrier to entry. Plus, it’s something that people can actually play together, which is always a bonus at a party.

Here’s why it’s a great choice:

  • It’s easy to learn.
  • It’s engaging for a wide range of ages.
  • It can accommodate multiple players (usually 2-4).

3. Waterproof Bluetooth Speaker

Okay, so maybe not everyone needs a waterproof Bluetooth speaker, but who wouldn’t want one? This is a gift that combines practicality with a touch of luxury, making it a prime target for theft at any White Elephant party.

I mean, think about it: shower karaoke, poolside tunes, or even just jamming out while doing dishes. A Bluetooth speaker is a versatile gadget that can be used in so many situations. Plus, the fact that it’s waterproof adds an extra layer of durability and peace of mind. No more worrying about splashes or accidental drops in the sink!

I got one of these last year, and it’s been a game-changer. I use it all the time, and it’s surprisingly loud for its size. Definitely a crowd-pleaser.

4. Desk Calendar

Who doesn’t need to keep track of the days? A desk calendar is a practical gift that can also be funny or inspirational, depending on the theme. You can find calendars with hilarious cat pictures, motivational quotes, or even historical events.

A calendar is a gift that keeps on giving all year long. It’s something people will actually use, making it a great choice for a white elephant party where practicality and humor are both appreciated.

Here are some ideas for making it a hit:

  • Go for a theme: Find a calendar that matches the recipient’s interests, like a 2025 wall calendar featuring their favorite hobby or TV show.
  • Choose a funny one: A calendar with silly jokes or absurd images is always a crowd-pleaser.
  • Consider a unique design: Look for a calendar with a creative layout or unusual materials.

5. Wineglasses

Two elegant wineglasses, filled with red wine.

Wineglasses are a classic white elephant gift, and for good reason! Everyone can use a nice set of glasses, whether they’re a wine connoisseur or just enjoy the occasional glass. But to make this gift truly steal-worthy, think beyond the basic.

  • Consider a set of stemless wineglasses. They’re modern, less prone to tipping, and perfect for casual gatherings.
  • Look for glasses with a unique design or interesting shape. Something that stands out from the usual glassware.
  • A set of colorful wineglasses can add a fun touch to any party.

A good set of wineglasses can really elevate the experience of enjoying wine. It’s a gift that’s both practical and adds a touch of elegance to any home. Plus, who doesn’t love a good excuse to open a bottle of wine?

For an extra touch, you could include a pickle wine stopper or a bottle of wine (depending on the rules of your white elephant party, of course!). This turns a simple gift into a complete package that anyone would be happy to receive. You could also include some design lover chopsticks.

6. Ultra-Soft Blanket

Who doesn’t love a good blanket? Seriously, it’s a gift that’s hard to go wrong with, especially for a White Elephant party. Forget scratchy wool; we’re talking ultra-soft here. Think the kind of blanket that makes you want to curl up on the couch with a good book and a cup of hot cocoa.

The key is to find one that’s ridiculously cozy. I’m talking about the kind of blanket that people will actually fight over. A cozy throw blanket with pompom detailing could be a great choice.

I remember one year, someone brought a super plush blanket to our White Elephant exchange, and it was the most stolen item of the night. People were practically tackling each other to get their hands on it. It was hilarious, but it also proved how much everyone appreciates a good, soft blanket.

Here’s what to look for when choosing an ultra-soft blanket:

  • Material: Microfiber, fleece, or even a faux fur are great options.
  • Size: Go for a throw size that’s big enough to snuggle under but not too bulky.
  • Color/Pattern: Choose something neutral or festive, depending on the vibe of the party.

And hey, if you’re feeling extra generous, you could even include a donut blanket to complete the cozy package!

7. Festive Decorations

Colorful holiday decorations on a mantelpiece.

Let’s be real, who doesn’t love a little sparkle? Festive decorations are a fantastic choice for a White Elephant gift because they can be used immediately or saved for the next holiday season. Plus, there’s a wide range of options to fit different tastes and budgets. You can find some unique Etsy gift ideas for decorations.

Think beyond the usual tinsel and ornaments. Consider items that can be used year-round, like string lights or decorative lanterns. These add a touch of whimsy to any space, making them a gift that keeps on giving.

Here are some ideas to get you started:

  • Themed string lights: Battery-operated string lights in fun shapes (stars, snowflakes, etc.) are always a hit.
  • Miniature disco ball: A small disco ball can instantly transform any room into a party zone.
  • Seasonal banners: Banners with festive messages or designs are easy to hang and add a pop of color.

8. Homemade Items

Homemade gifts can be a huge hit at a White Elephant party, especially if they’re creative or funny. It shows you put in effort, and that can make your gift stand out. Plus, it’s a great way to save money while still bringing something awesome to the party. Think about what you’re good at making and go from there. It’s all about the personal touch!

Making something yourself adds a unique element to the gift exchange. It’s not just about the item itself, but the thought and effort behind it. This can lead to some hilarious and memorable moments as people fight over your creation.

Here are a few ideas to get you started:

  • Baked Goods: Everyone loves treats! Cookies, brownies, or even a loaf of homemade bread are always appreciated. Package them nicely for extra points.
  • DIY Kits: Put together a kit for something fun, like a hot chocolate mix with marshmallows and sprinkles, or a chocolate bar-making kit with various toppings.
  • Personalized Items: A hand-painted mug, a knitted scarf, or a custom-made candle can be a thoughtful and unique gift. Get creative with colors and designs!

9. Gag Gifts

Gag gifts are a staple of any good white elephant party. They’re the gifts that are meant to get a laugh, and sometimes, they’re so bad they’re good. The key is to find something that’s funny without being offensive, and that’s a challenge!

Remember, the goal is to entertain, not to offend. Think about your audience and what they’d find funny. A little bit of creativity can go a long way in creating a memorable gag gift.

The best gag gifts are unexpected and memorable. Humor is subjective, so what one person finds hilarious, another might find totally lame. But that’s part of the fun, right? It’s all about the reaction you get when someone opens it.

10. Kitchen Appliance

Let’s be real, everyone loves a good kitchen gadget. It’s the kind of gift that’s both practical and potentially hilarious, especially if it’s something nobody knew they needed. Think outside the box – or inside the kitchen cabinet, I guess!

  • Mini Waffle Maker: These things are all the rage. They’re small, cute, and perfect for making individual waffles, paninis, or even cookies. It’s a fun way to add a little novelty to breakfast.
  • Yonanas Soft Serve Maker: Turn frozen fruit into a healthy and delicious dessert in minutes. It’s dishwasher-safe and includes a recipe book.
  • Mixing Bowl Set: A set of ceramic mixing bowls with measuring lines and pour spouts is both cute and useful. It’s a practical gift that anyone can appreciate.

I remember one year, someone brought a popcorn maker to our white elephant party. It was a total hit! Everyone was fighting over it, and we ended up making popcorn all night. It just goes to show that sometimes the simplest gifts are the best.

Consider a unique kitchen gift that will be the talk of the party.

Looking for awesome kitchen stuff? We’ve got a bunch of cool gadgets and tools that make cooking and baking way easier. Check out our top picks and find the perfect appliance for your home. Visit our website to see all the great options!

Wrapping Up Your White Elephant Hunt

So, there you have it! Finding the perfect white elephant gift doesn’t have to be a headache. It’s really about picking something fun, useful, or just plain interesting that anyone would be happy to get. Whether you go for something practical, a little bit silly, or a total surprise, the main goal is to make sure your gift is the one everyone wants to snag. Happy gifting, and may your white elephant party be full of laughs and friendly competition!

Frequently Asked Questions

What is a White Elephant gift exchange?

White Elephant is a fun gift exchange game, also called Yankee Swap or Dirty Santa. Players pick numbers, then either choose a new gift or “steal” one that someone else already opened. It’s a great way to have some playful fun at holiday parties.

What makes a good White Elephant gift?

The best gifts are ones that most people would like and find useful. Think about things like cool gadgets, cozy blankets, or nice kitchen items. The goal is to pick something that others will want to take from you!

Does a White Elephant gift have to be funny?

Not at all! While some people enjoy giving funny or silly gifts, the best White Elephant gifts are often things people will actually use. It depends on who will be at the party. If it’s your close friends, a funny inside joke gift might work. For a work party, a more practical item is usually better.

Is there usually a price limit for White Elephant gifts?

Many White Elephant parties have a price limit, like under $20 or $50. This helps keep things fair and makes sure no one spends too much. Always check with the party host about any spending rules.

Can I regift an item I received in a White Elephant exchange?

Yes, sometimes. If you get a gift you don’t really want, you might be able to trade it with someone else, or you might just keep it and regift it later. It depends on the rules of the specific game.

Should White Elephant gifts be wrapped?

It’s a good idea to bring a gift that is wrapped so it’s a surprise. This adds to the fun of the game, as no one knows what’s inside until it’s opened.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top